The teacher-student relationship is one of the most beneficial ones that has ever existed, and yet it can sometimes break down into an adversarial relationship. A friend of mine likes to say that most of us have a rather harsh image of God: we think God is like our 8th Grade algebra teacher who was always out to get us. If there are teachers who are out to get us, surely there are students who like to make their teacher look bad. Back in my high school, one of my friends loved to play pranks. On one occasion, the teacher, Mrs. DeLorme, had to go down to the office, and she told the class to read quietly during her brief absence, but instead the class decided to move across the hall into an empty classroom at the suggestion of my friend, of course! Soon Mrs. DeLorme returned, and seeing that her class had gone AWOL, she went back down to the office to report this violation of rules. At this point, the class moved back across the hall, back into the correct classroom. When Mrs. DeLorme returned with the principal, she was shocked to find the class sitting quietly, reading just as she had instructed them. She was completely baffled, and the principal just shook his head as he walked away. I think Mrs. DeLorme retired that year.
Usually, such tricks are played in fun; but with Jesus’ enemies, it was serious business! They were constantly looking for ways to trap Jesus in escape‑proof traps. They were always trying to make Him look bad in public. They challenged Him when He broke their “Blue Laws” by practicing medicine (healing) on the Sabbath or when He plucked and ate grain on the Sabbath. They tried to get Him to contradict the Law of Moses and they accused Him of so doing when He ate with sinners. They even tried to get Him in trouble with the Romans over tax laws. But no trap was as cleverly laid as the one recorded in John 8.
Let me give you a brief background of this story because it makes serious in‑depth Bible study so fascinating! The New Testament was written in Greek and later translated into Latin. Since there were no Kinkos or Xerox machines in those days, copies of the texts had to be made by the hands of scribes. There are many of these ancient copies of the New Testament books, collected from all over the Middle East. In the earliest manuscripts of John’s Gospel, John 8:1‑11 is not present at all. In two ancient texts, a blank space exists after John 7 closes. The story of the woman caught in adultery had a hard time making it into our Bible because nobody knew where to put it. St. Augustine thought that the story was suppressed by the early church in order to avoid a scandal. Judging by the writing style and the choice of words, scholars say that there is no way that John could be the author of this story. It is more likely to have been written by Luke. Indeed, in some ancient manuscripts, this story is inserted after Luke 21:38. So, apparently, this is a short story written by Luke. No one in the early church doubted its authenticity. This certainly occurred in Jesus’ ministry. They just didn’t know where to record it, but it was too good to lose! Finally after the 6th Century A. D., it found its permanent home in John’s gospel.
And as I said, this was the cleverest trap ever set for Jesus. It was a trap with four blocked exits. First, if Jesus appeared soft on the issue of adultery, His enemies could discredit Him in the eyes of religious people. He would be guilty of condoning what was considered a heinous sin according to Jewish Law. Secondly, if Jesus was harsh toward the woman, encouraging people to stone her, an act which was forbidden by Roman Law, Jesus’ opponents could accuse Him before the Roman authorities of illegally inciting others to kill the woman. He would then be arrested and be out of the way. Thirdly, if Jesus was not merciful to the woman, many of His followers, sinners and outcasts, would abandon Him. He would look bad in the eyes of the sinners who had found new hope in Christ. The fourth trap was the fact that not only was Jesus’ attitude toward adultery in question; His attitude toward the Law of Moses as a whole, His attitude toward morality, was in question.
What a trap! How would Jesus uphold the integrity of the Law and at the same time hold out mercy to a sinner without being held in violation of Roman and Jewish Law? Jesus had to think this over! He stooped down and doodled in the dirt. Perhaps He wished that the earth would swallow Him up! Now, Jesus’ drawing in the dirt has been the subject of much speculation! Perhaps Jesus looked down at the ground because of some sense of modesty that resided in His heart, making it difficult for Him to even glance at the improperly clothed (or unclothed) woman. Some have suggested that while He was drawing in the dirt, perhaps Jesus looked each man in the eye, and since He knew each one’s heart, He wrote each one’s secret sin in the dirt. Facing man #1 Jesus wrote: “You dishonored your parents.” Facing man #2 Jesus wrote: “You stole money from your neighbor.” Jesus continued until each one knew that Jesus knew their sin, so that when Jesus said, “He who is without sin among you, let him cast the first stone,” they all knew that they would be hypocrites to hurl the rocks. That is one possibility. Another possibility is given by T.W. Manson and The Cambridge Bible Commentary on the New English Bible. Manson says that Jesus was acting like a Roman judge who always wrote his sentence before pronouncing it. My favorite theory is that Jesus was wisely buying time, thinking and praying His way out of this trap. If that is true, He was giving us a good example of what to do when we feel trapped, not knowing which way to turn. A moment to think and pray would be very helpful to us. And as Jesus thought, several things must have occurred to Him.
First, Jesus must have perceived that the real issue here wasn’t adultery or marriage. If that was the issue, Jesus wouldn’t have hesitated to teach as He had in Matthew 19. Jesus knew that the real issue here was “trying to trap the teacher.” Secondly, it was clear that this poor woman had been entrapped. An undercover agent (if you’ll pardon the phrase) had been hired to lure this woman into sin. How else would she be caught in the very act of her sin? Thirdly, not only had they plotted to catch this woman, now they were using her for their evil purposes. They were belittling her in public for their evil scheme. How it must have angered Jesus to see people entrap a weak, tender child of God and use her as their pawn! It must also anger Him today when people slander others to make themselves look good or when we use people as if they were things. Fourthly, it occurred to Jesus that they were delighting in condemning her. Often it seems that self-righteous people find comfort in condemning others, thinking they will feel more righteous by comparison. And, what is it about the guilt we feel over our own sin that makes us want to see others suffer for theirs? Do we think we will thereby feel cleaner? Perhaps misery loves company!
Jesus was troubled by their attitude. They were rejoicing over her sin when they should be weeping! And we should also weep each time a child of God has to go to prison and each time a child of God is executed because it means that someone has failed another human being and God. We failed to teach them the right way to live.
I heard about a fire and brimstone church that ran off their preacher and got a new one. Someone in town asked them what their new pastor preached about, and they replied, “He tells us each week that we are going to hell.” The man then said, “Well, that’s what you complained about with your old preacher. You said that you got tired of him telling you that week after week.” The church member said, “Well, this new preacher is different. He seems genuinely sorry that we might end up in hell, but our old preacher seemed almost happy at that prospect.”
As Jesus stooped and drew in the dirt, He must have wondered which is the worse sin: a woman swept up by passion or the men who tricked, trapped, and used this woman with such delight. It was clear to Jesus. A sin of passion was one thing, but a cold, calculating, dehumanizing sin was worse! This woman knew her sin; these men must be made to see theirs! “Look into your hearts,” Jesus said, “and if you find no sin there, then cast a stone.” One by one, these men had to admit that if they were going to judge a person so strictly by the Law, they had to be that strict on themselves, too, and they couldn’t stand up under such scrutiny either. One by one they slunk away, leaving just Jesus and the woman.
In one of the movies about the life of Christ, this story is beautifully done. Jesus picks up a large stone and tries to hand it to each person in the crowd. As He hands the rock to each one, the person turns away in shame. As Jesus turns to the woman and says, “Woman, where are your accusers?” He still has the stone in His hand. The woman replies, “No one accuses me.” Jesus raises the rock up over His head like He was about to throw it. The woman cowers, expecting Jesus to hurl the stone at her. After all, He was the only one in the crowd who was without sin. Then Jesus throws the rock straight down at His feet, and as it rolls away from the woman, Jesus says, “Neither do I condemn thee!”
What wonderful words of comfort this should be to all of us! For someday, each of us will stand in Christ’s presence, one to one, eyeball to eyeball. Our lives and our sin will be examined by the One Who is the Judge of the living and the dead. Then we will hear Jesus say, “I don’t condemn thee. I gave my life for you.” “For God did not send His son into the world to condemn the world but to save it.” But why wait until Judgment Day? Today we can all hear Jesus say to us “I do not condemn you; I have saved you.”
So Jesus has been merciful to the woman; only one thing remained to be done: the Law must be upheld; sin must be shown to be wrong because it hurts us. Ultimately Jesus would die to uphold the law and at the same time lift up the sinner. But for the present Jesus upholds the law by warning the woman, “Go now and leave your life of sin.” Jesus says to us when we are on the verge of messing up our lives, “Don’t do that to yourself ‑ I love you too much to see you injure yourself!” But I don’t think that Jesus had to worry too much about that woman. She had been scared almost to death; now she felt loved and forgiven. She was a new creation ‑ the old had passed away. In the words of Paul, she had experienced the depths of God’s love!
The central message of this story is “The one who is without sin among you, let him cast the first stone.” This is a reminder that each of us has a full time job keeping our own lives straight without meddling in others’ lives! And if we are tempted to judge and condemn others, there is plenty in ourselves to judge and condemn! It therefore behooves us to be merciful to one another even as we would want to receive mercy. Or said another way, “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.”
Well, once again Jesus was trapped and He escaped by thinking and praying before He spoke and by a display of His unique wisdom. He upheld the moral code. He upheld one who needed grace, who had failed to keep the law. He upheld civil law by seeing that Roman law was not broken. He sends us out to uphold moral integrity and to extend mercy to those who fail, to offer them God’s forgiveness and pardon! Amen.
Arthur H. Holt
Don't forget our monthly catered meal Wed., Sept. 1 from 5:30-7 p.m. in the Social Hall. Call June Melton at 877-0956 to RSVP!
Mark your calendars now for the annual United Methodist Mens Pancake Supper on Sept. 21 in the Family Life Center. Details soon.
Recent Comments